“Innovation doesn’t guarantee investment returns.” — Howard Marks

Crypto as an Asset Class: Framework

The financial landscape is rarely disrupted by the arrival of an entirely new asset class. Most "new" investment opportunities are simply repackaged versions of existing ones—new ways to lend money, buy equity, or speculate on commodities.

Crypto-assets, however, represent a unique challenge for the disciplined investor. They do not produce cash flows, they lack a central authority, and they are governed by code rather than boardrooms. Because of this, they are often surrounded by extreme rhetoric.

To the disciplined investor, rhetoric is noise. To find clarity, we must move past the hype and the fear, applying the same analytical rigor to crypto that we would to any other component of a portfolio. This framework treats crypto not as a movement, but as a data point within the broader category of [Alternative Investments].

Defining the Asset Characteristics

The first step in any analytical framework is classification. Crypto-assets are difficult to categorize because they exhibit "chameleon-like" properties depending on the market environment.

They act like commodities in the sense that they are "mined" (digitally) and have a finite or programmed supply. They act like technology equities because their value is often tied to the growth and adoption of the underlying network. Occasionally, they are viewed as currencies, though their extreme volatility currently prevents them from functioning as a stable medium of exchange or unit of account.

Crucially, crypto-assets are non-productive assets. Unlike a stock, which represents a claim on future earnings, or a bond, which represents a claim on interest payments, a crypto-asset produces nothing. Its value is derived entirely from supply, demand, and the perceived utility of the network. This makes traditional valuation—such as a Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis—impossible.

The Reality of Volatility and Risk

In institutional investing, risk is often measured by standard deviation (volatility) and maximum drawdown (the peak-to-trough decline). By these metrics, crypto-assets are among the most volatile instruments available to the public.

It is common for "blue-chip" crypto-assets to experience drawdowns of 70% to 90%. For an investor, this requires a level of behavioral discipline that exceeds what is required for traditional equities. If a 20% drop in the S&P 500 causes an investor to panic, a crypto allocation will likely lead to poor decision-making at the worst possible time.

[Internal link: Asset Allocation Matters More Than Asset Selection]

The risk is not merely market volatility, but "permanent loss of capital." In the equity market, a diversified index has historically recovered from every crash. In the crypto-asset space, thousands of individual assets have gone to zero and stayed there. This necessitates a focus on "survival" rather than "optimization."

Correlation: The Diversification Myth

One of the primary arguments for adding crypto to a portfolio was its supposed lack of correlation with traditional markets. The theory suggested that if stocks fell, crypto might stay flat or rise, providing a hedge.

Historical data from the last five years has largely challenged this. Crypto-assets have shown a high positive correlation with "risk-on" assets, particularly the NASDAQ and high-growth tech stocks. When global liquidity is high and interest rates are low, crypto tends to perform well. When the Federal Reserve tightens liquidity, crypto often leads the market lower.

Investors should not view crypto as a hedge against a stock market crash. Instead, it should be viewed as a high-beta play on global liquidity. It does not diversify away from market risk; it amplifies it.

Framing the Role in a Portfolio

If an investor decides to include crypto in their portfolio, it must have a defined role. Within the Investing Overload framework, we categorize this as a "speculative sleeve."

There are two primary ways to approach allocation:

1. The Fixed Percentage: An investor allocates a small, fixed amount (e.g., 1% to 5%) of their total portfolio. This allows for exposure to the potential "asymmetric upside"—where the gains could be 10x or 100x—while ensuring that a total loss of the asset does not jeopardize the investor's long-term financial goals.

2. The Rebalancing Harvest: Because of crypto's extreme volatility, a disciplined rebalancing strategy can be effective. Selling a portion of the position when it grows beyond the target allocation and buying when it crashes can "harvest" the volatility, essentially forcing the investor to buy low and sell high.

[Internal link: The Hidden Costs of Alternative Assets]

Without a rules-based approach to sizing and rebalancing, a crypto allocation often becomes a source of emotional stress rather than a strategic advantage.

Operational Tradeoffs and Custody

Investing in crypto-assets introduces risks that do not exist in the brokerage world. In a traditional brokerage account, your assets are protected by layers of regulation and insurance. In crypto, the burden of security often falls on the investor.

• Self-Custody: Holding your own "keys" provides total control but introduces the risk of human error. If a password is lost, the capital is gone forever.

• Institutional Products: The rise of ETFs and regulated custodians has made crypto more accessible. However, these products often come with management fees and strip away some of the "decentralized" benefits of the asset.

• Regulatory Risk: Governments around the world are still determining how to tax and regulate these assets. A sudden change in policy can impact liquidity and price discovery overnight.

Opportunity Cost

Every dollar allocated to crypto is a dollar not invested in a productive, dividend-paying company or a yield-generating bond. This is the opportunity cost.

Over long horizons, the compounding effect of productive assets is the most reliable path to wealth. Crypto-assets, being non-productive, rely entirely on "price appreciation." An investor must ask: "Am I sacrificing a proven compounding machine for a speculative network?"

A Disciplined Conclusion

The decision to hold crypto-assets should not be based on a belief in a "financial revolution" or the fear of missing out. It should be a calculated decision based on your personal risk budget and your ability to remain disciplined during extreme market stress.

A framework for crypto-assets requires acknowledging three truths:

1. The asset is highly volatile and has no floor based on cash flows.

2. The asset is currently a proxy for market liquidity, not a hedge against it.

3. Position sizing is the only reliable form of risk management.

If you cannot define why you own it, how much you are willing to lose, and at what price you will sell, you are not investing; you are gambling. Discipline in asset selection is secondary to discipline in behavior.

For those looking to build a resilient portfolio, the focus should remain on the core pillars of diversification. Crypto may have a place on the periphery, but it is the structure of the whole that determines long-term success.

Next Step: Review your current asset allocation. Does your exposure to volatile alternatives exceed your "sleep at night" threshold? Continue your research by exploring our guide on [The Role of Gold in a Modern Portfolio].

Related Stories